It’s one of the greatest barstool debates of all-time. Who is the greatest quarterback in NFL history? It’s easy to make a case for or against any of these guys: Johnny Unitas, Joe Montana, John Elway, Dan Marino, Brett Favre, Tom Brady and Peyton Manning.
Old timers will tell you that Unitas is the greatest of all-time. When I asked Hall of Fame quarterback Dan Fouts about this debate (by the way, I felt awful about asking one of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time, who was better than him), Unitas was the first name out of his mouth. He added, “It’s too difficult to compare eras.” Fair enough. I never saw Unitas play, so let’s make a case for the greatest quarterback in the last 40 years.
Picking the greatest quarterback is like asking a millionaire to pick his favorite car in his garage. All of them are great. Each is unique. Each is special.
The Broncos will face the greatest on Sunday in Indianapolis.
The Colts are Manning’s team. Montana played for Walsh. Elway played for Reeves and Shanahan. Marino played Shula. Favre played for Holmgren. Brady plays for Belichick. The Colts play for Manning; he didn’t play for Tony Dungy.
Manning’s football IQ is arguably the highest in NFL history. He calls his own plays. Johnny Unitas and Buffalo Bills quarterback Jim Kelly also called their own plays for many seasons, but you can’t say that consistently about the other guys. Manning understands the complexities of today’s offense and defense better than anyone who has played the game over the last 40 years.
When Manning retires, he will likely hold every major passing record. He already has the best quarterback rating and completion percentage compared to all of these guys.
All of them do have one thing in common, however. They make the players around them better, but no one does it better than Manning.
When the Colts drafted Austin Collie this year, the rookie got a phone call less than 24 hours later from Manning. The future Hall of Famer told the wide receiver, “Meet me at the practice facility at 8:00 a.m. to start work.”
Many are fawning over Brett Favre this year and rightfully so. It’s amazing to see a 40-year-old quarterback put up the best numbers of his career. However, Manning has done far more with less on offense.
The Colts don’t have a running game and their second and third wide receiver options read more like a “who’s that?” than a “who’s who” in the game program.
Manning should unquestionably win his fourth Most Valuable Player award. Take him off the team and the Colts have a top-five pick in the draft. Take Favre off the Vikings and they’re still competitive with Adrian Peterson and a pretty good defense.
It’s staggering to look at the numbers for the Colts wide receivers. Pierre Garcon and Austin Collie had caught a combined four passes going into this season. Through 12 games, they have a combined 90 catches for more than 1,200 yards. They run great routes because Manning demands it.
If Colts head coach Jim Caldwell were in Tampa right now, he’d be doing no better than Raheem Morris. Caldwell is the coach in name only. Manning runs this team.
Manning forced one of the greatest coaches off all time, Bill Belichick, to blink on fourth-and-two earlier this season. He led another fourth-quarter comeback and it wasn’t even close to his greatest comeback of all-time. Manning has the rare ability to change games without being on the field.
This guy is more than just numbers. It’s the eye test that makes him great. He’s a tremendous decision maker. He always finds the open receiver. He’s the best student of the game and this has made him the best at reading defenses. When he drops back to pass, you expect him to complete it every time. You certainly can’t say that about Elway and Favre.
Some will say that Montana and Brady are system quarterbacks. Manning is the system. He’s the quarterback and the offensive coordinator.
Many believe that quarterback sacks are solely the responsibility of the offensive line. This isn’t always true. Manning has been sacked 10 times this season behind a marginal offensive line. He knows when to get rid of the ball. He calls the right play to make sure he hits the right receiver when the defense is blitzing.
The argument against Manning is simple: He has one Super Bowl title, and he really wasn’t even good in that game. This is true.
Dan Marino will never be called the greatest because he never won the Super Bowl. Favre has been to a pair and won one. What Montana, Brady, and Elway have accomplished is mind boggling. However, all of these guys had a lot of help when they won the Super Bowl.
Montana had the greatest offensive system of all-time to go with Hall of Famer Jerry Rice, Roger Craig and a very good defense. Brady had a very good offensive system and a great defense. Elway was a one man show in the 1980s (so was Marino), but won a pair of titles with Terrell Davis, future Hall of Famer Shannon Sharpe, Hall of Famer Gary Zimmerman and a defense that was good enough.
Elway is the most athletically gifted quarterback of all time, but not the greatest. Elway was great, but not consistent like Manning or Montana. Sorry, folks. My hometown bias doesn’t match yours.
Manning, barring injury, could play another five to six years. He will likely hold all of the major passing records by the time he retires. He will also get a chance to play in a few more Super Bowls. He is arguably having his finest season, and he’s doing it on his own on offense.
Joe Namath told a colleague of mine a few years ago that Manning will be the greatest whether he wins a Super Bowl or not. Manning already has one. The next one makes this barstool debate a moot point for the previous 40 years and likely the next 40 to come.
Comments [0]